My question is why does it matter if they would have taken him back, in my opinion Rodgers would have still be starting anyways. Why? simple, you really think favre could take the hits that Rodgers has been taking...even half of them? Favre is delicate whether he or anyone else likes it and Minnesota proved that by protecting him by all means...could the packers do the same for him? Doubt it. Both him and the packers are better off...the way the situation was handled was poor to say the least though.